Tuesday, July 3, 2012


Ch. 4 Guided Reading

            With younger children guided reading helps children develop an appreciation and understanding of the story and at the same time stimulates problem-solving conversations about how to apply reading strategies in context which leads to competent independent reading (p. 41).  This chapter details the elements and types of guided reading that can start in Kinder and 1st  then onto 2nd and 3rd grade .    When children show signs of print awareness such as:  knowing the difference between letters and words, explore print on walls, notice that same words appear over and over in different contexts, etc… it is time for guided reading.

            Book selection should be based on children’s level of knowledge and experience as well as meets the goal of instruction.  The focus at the beginning is to prepare kids through matching one-to-one, using first letter cues, noticing chunks, or what do students do at point of difficulty?  As students become more competent they can discuss characters, plot, author’s writing style, characteristics of the genre or literary devices used by the author.  During the book introduction the teacher helps children build meaning with a brief overview, exposes them to structure by identifying language phrases and patterns and introduces the children to visual or graphophonetic cues by finding frequently encountered words they know or predict words using first letter cues which are all sources of information that independent readers use.  

            I have seen teachers use guided reading and have done this myself and round robin reading seemed to come into play here but the book stated “Each child begins reading at his or her own pace.” Instructional interactions with the children are determined by children’s’ strengths and needs. In this small group activity, class size is important and ability levels have to match so that the support matches the level of the group.  I have observed students less capable of reading at their own pace so they begin to parrot a more able reader sitting next to them.  I have also seen guided reading begin as partner reading when developmentally students are not at the stage of helping one another effectively.  The important aspect of guided reading at the kinder and first grade level is the teachers’ ability to observe children’s processing behavior and responding appropriately because this is where students are learning to read.

            For more fluent readers say in 2nd and 3rd, book selection is based on interest, content, thematic units and story genre with complex structures such as repetition, cumulative, cultural, chronological, problem-centered, and rhythm and rhyme.  This is where students begin reading to learn as they see how information is presented in a variety of ways, make comparisons and contrasts between texts, explore author’s style, develop comprehension skills, and increase mastery of story elements.  One of the statements that caught my attention was when the authors stated that instead of introducing vocabulary words or potentially difficult words before reading the story the teacher should select one or two appropriate words  to discuss and build knowledge of the word or to use magnetic letters or white board to illustrate problem-solving techniques after the first read.  This contrasts with most reading programs where vocabulary is introduced before the first read.  So students have to incorporate their reading strategies full force during the time students are reading silently.  The scenarios in the book give explicit examples of how guided reading should look like and the role of the teacher.

            What happens to guided reading when questions at the end of a story becomes the priority rather than reading to learn?     

5 comments:

  1. In response to your closing question, I believe that when an assessment, informal or formal, the joy of the reading experience is taken away from the students.

    Like we've read in our numerous articles, apprenticeship and explicit instruction are key for student success. I truly believe that guided reading plays a large role in these steps.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Yes I think you are right. With guided reading students can enjoy the stories and love to read.

    This would be producing life long readers and learners in our communities.

    ReplyDelete
  3. I think too often we use the comprehension quesions at the end of a text as the measurement of our students' reading performance. As a result, we tend to focus less on the reading process itself and focus more on answering those questions in the end. I think one of the solutions is to incorporate those end-of-a-text questions into the guided reading process and use those questions to encourage thinking and discussion. I think it is almost like shooting two birds with one stone: you got those questions answered and you are able to assess if students have understood the text, both during the process of guided reading.

    ReplyDelete
  4. Yes it can be seen like that. In our elluminate session we discussed efferent stance and aesthetic stance to reading. Efferent stance is reading for information like how to do something or gaining factual information. Aesthetic stance is reading for enjoyment at a deeper level like connecting with the story to experience what is happening in the reading.
    From what you said is there a way to combine the two stances?

    ReplyDelete
  5. In response to your closing question, I am not really sure how to answer that question :( but I think I would have to agree with Thomas when he said, "I believe that when an assessment, informal or formal, the joy of the reading experience is taken away from the students."

    ReplyDelete